scratches on car

What Evidence is Most Useful for Establishing Liability After a Car Accident?

Updated January 24, 2024.

Accidents on the road can turn life upside down in an instant. Understanding the evidence that proves liability is crucial for victims seeking justice and compensation. Please continue reading and reach out to a competent Rochester car accident lawyer from Lacy Katzen LLP to learn more about what types of evidence are most effective in establishing liability after a car accident and how our legal team can help you fight for the compensation you deserve.

What Role Does Evidence Play in a Car Accident Case?

In car accident cases, evidence serves as the foundation for establishing who is at fault. It helps demonstrate negligence, which is essential for liability. Without concrete evidence, proving responsibility becomes challenging, often leading to disputes and prolonged legal battles.

The Five Most Useful Forms of Evidence

  1. Photographs and Videos: Photographs and videos taken immediately after the accident can provide irrefutable proof of the scene. They capture details like vehicle positions, traffic signals, skid marks, and road conditions, which can be critical in determining fault. In today’s digital age, dashcam footage or nearby surveillance cameras can also offer a dynamic view of the incident, capturing the collision in real-time.
  2. Police Reports: A police report is a neutral, authoritative document that records the details of the accident. It often includes the officer’s observations, statements from involved parties, and sometimes an initial assessment of fault. The report might also note any traffic law violations, such as speeding or running a red light, which can be critical in establishing liability.
  3. Witness Statements: Witnesses offer independent accounts of the accident, which can corroborate or dispute the involved parties’ versions of events. These statements can be from bystanders, other drivers, or pedestrians who observed the accident. Their perspective can be particularly useful in cases where the parties involved have conflicting accounts of what happened.
  4. Medical Records: Medical records are a direct testament to the injuries suffered as a result of the accident. They include initial medical evaluations, treatment records, doctor’s notes, and prognosis reports. These documents not only establish the extent and severity of the injuries but also link them causally to the accident, which is critical for claiming compensation.
  5. Expert Testimonies: Experts such as accident reconstruction specialists, automotive engineers, or medical professionals provide specialized knowledge that can clarify complex aspects of the case. An accident reconstruction expert, for example, can analyze the evidence to determine the dynamics of the crash, like the speed at which the vehicles were traveling, the point of impact, and the forces involved. These insights are instrumental in piecing together the exact sequence of events leading to the accident.

Importantly, if you’ve sustained an injury in a car accident due to no fault of your own, it’s imperative that you retain the services of a competent Rochester car accident lawyer who can effectively work to gather and present all evidence needed to satisfy the burden of proof in your personal injury claim. Fortunately, you’ve come to the right place. Contact Lacy Katzen LLP today.


Read our latest news and blogs that discuss important legal issues.

person writing with a pen on a table next to a calculator
Understanding New York State and Federal Estate Taxes: Be Aware of the Potential 2026 Cliff
Read More
nursing home resident with staff member
What Rights Do Nursing Home Patients Have in NYS?
Read More
attorney helping client draft a document
5 Reasons to Hire a Real Estate Attorney
Read More

Get in touch

Please do not provide any sensitive information (i.e. bank account information or social security number).

"*" indicates required fields

Why Choose Lacy Katzen

Our mission is to ethically serve our clients with excellence and teamwork each day.

Over 73 Years of Experience
Nine Attorneys Listed in Best Lawyers in America®
Ranked by Best Lawyers as a Best Law Firm®
Six Attorneys Named as Super Lawyers
One Attorney is a Fellow at the American College of Trial Lawyers

Accessibility Toolbar